Welcome to Paesanos Pizzeria
At Paesanos Pizzeria, nestled in the heart of Liberty, NY, we take pride in crafting authentic New York-style pizza that delights every palate. Our story is one of passion for fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes, manifesting in every slice of our thin-crust pie. Customers rave about our specialty pizzas, including the fan-favorite Margherita topped with pesto and fresh mozzarella. With a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of classic NYC pizzerias, we create a dining experience that’s both comforting and delicious. Whether you’re stopping for a quick slice or a hearty meal, Paesanos promises exceptional food and friendly service that keeps everyone coming back for more.
-
10 S Main St #1813, Liberty, NY 12754 Hotline: (845) 292-7510
Welcome to the delightful world of Paesanos Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Liberty, NY. Located at 10 S Main St #1813, this pizzeria has earned a loyal following for delivering mouthwatering pies that evoke the rich culinary traditions of New York City. With just a phone call to (845) 292-7510, you can immerse yourself in the flavors that have captivated locals and visitors alike.
As you step into Paesanos Pizzeria, expect to be greeted by a charming atmosphere reminiscent of classic New York pizza parlors. The décor may be humble, but the flavor is anything but. Each dish is crafted with care, showcasing the passion and expertise of the kitchen. The pizzeria offers an impressive selection, from the beloved Plain Cheese Pizza starting at just $8.00 to the indulgent Margarita Pie, adorned with fresh mozzarella and pesto, ensuring there's something for everyone.
- Sicilian Pizza: A hearty option, the Plain Sicilian is available for just $12.00.
- Pizza by the Slice: Take a quick bite with a Cheese Pizza Slice for only $1.60.
- Garlic Knots: A must-try, these delightful bites are said to keep the vampires away!
Customer feedback showcases the pizzeria's dedication to quality. Kathleen C. proclaims it to be "the best pizza north of NYC," and many travelers, like Frank N., make it a point to commute from afar just to savor the crispy, thin-crust pizzas. Algernon H. echoes this sentiment, encouraging those in Sullivan County to indulge in the delectable offerings that extend beyond pizza, including tasty pasta and chicken cutlet dinners. The consistent praise for the prompt and friendly service adds to the welcoming charm of Paesanos.
With each bite, you can taste the care and commitment put into the food. As Susan P. observed, even if the restaurant itself may not stand out, the flavors certainly do. Whether you’re enjoying a classic Plain Cheese Pizza, venturing into a rich White Pesto, or indulging in an Antipasto Salad on the side, every dish promises satisfaction.
So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop at Paesanos Pizzeria. Experience the charm, delicious food, and friendly service that countless reviewers rave about. Come for the pizza, and you may just leave with a new favorite dining destination.
Best pizza north of NYC!! I stop here every time I am in the area. He always has a variety of pizzas ready to go
I say, When outside of the NY metro area, it is often difficult to find good pizza. If you are in Sullivan County and looking for good pizza and entrees at economical prices, look no further! Whether NY style pizza, pasta, or Chicken Cutlet dinners, myself, nor my guests have never disappointed. Service is prompt and friendly and decor is that of a classic NY Parlor Good Show! Fare 4/5 Price $ PRO TIP: Try the garlic knots! They're enough to keep the vampires away!
Picked up two pies one plain, one with sausage and peppers. Very delicious, nice thin crust! Also got the antipasto salad for a side with the pizza. I travel from Smallwood to get this pizza, they're are plenty closer but its worth a 20 minute drive for fantastic pizza and food!
There food is Immaculately amazing, extra cheese pizza for my kids, They loved it I always go there. #Lovepasesanospizzeria
We found Paesanos by chance just stopping off the highway to grab some lunch that was not chain fast food. Wow. Talk about pleasantly surprised. The restaurant itself isn't much to look at, but the pizza is excellent. We're from Orange County and every time we go upstate, we make sure to stop at Paesanos on the way home. We've had plain pizza, sausage, fried eggplant, white pesto, and a few more. Never disappointed. I only wish they were in OC!
The margarita pie is the best. They put pesto sauce all over and use fresh mozzarella for this pie. It costs more than a regular pie but I never even tried the regular pie. I always get the margarita. They are friendly and the estimated time is usually right on point. They get busy on the weekends so you know its a popular place.
I was in upstate for work and I wanted a pizza. I got a large with the works. The crust was thin and had a nice crunch. The toppings tasted fresh and I really enjoyed it. I wish it had more sauce but, I like all my pizzas with more sauce. Next time I'm up that's way, I'll definitely call them again.